The Windmills of your Mind

I got back into my US copy of Psychonauts this weekend and finished The Milkman Conspiracies - bloody excellent stuff! I read today's re-review on EG and I think they're pretty much spot on with the 8. As much as I've previously protested that it wasn't just a platformer, it essentially is exactly that and it's more than a little frustrating in parts. I wonder just how it would have been received if it were a "proper" adventure game as compared to a bit of a mish-mash of different games.